Free Newsletter Subscription
        MCN All Access

A La Carte Lawsuit Will Proceed

Federal Judge Says Attorneys Raise Real Issues That Should Be Heard

By Linda Haugsted -- Multichannel News, 6/27/2008 6:20:00 AM

A federal judge in Los Angeles has refused to dismiss a potential class action lawsuit challenging the lack of a la carte programming offerings by video distributors and programmers.

Judge Christina Snyder, in a June 25 ruling, decided that the cable operators, direct-broadcast satellite companies and studios that were sued had not proved their arguments. Those companies alleged that the lawsuit, filed on antitrust grounds, did not adequately demonstrate that consumers were injured by the business practices of the defendants. In written and oral arguments on June 16, they also questioned the standing of the consumers to sue.

The ruling came in a December 2007 lawsuit, filed by consumers in four states on behalf of subscribers nationally. It was filed against NBC Universal Inc., Viacom Inc., The Walt Disney Co., Fox Entertainment Group, and Time Warner Inc. Distributors named in the suit are Comcast Corp., Coxcom Inc., The DirecTV Group Inc., Echostar Satellite LLC., Charter Communications and Cablevision Systems Corp.

The suit alleges the contracts between the programmers and distributors harm consumers because they force consumers to buy programming that they don't want or watch. Bundling programming causes consumers to overpay for their video options, according to the suit. 

But the judge ruled that attorneys for the consumers raise real issues that should be heard. She wrote that the programming owners that were sued control key broadcasting and cable channels and can use them to exclude independent programmers from the marketplace. That makes a case for a bona fide reduction in independent competition rather than "mere dissatisfaction by consumers with the choices in a well-functioning free market."

In March, the judge was going to dismiss the complaint as inadequate but instead allowed the consumers' attorneys to amend the suit. This version did not focus on a "conspiracy" between buyers and sellers and satisfied the judge.

Related Content

No related content found.

More >>>

Newbay Business Information Resource Center

Featured Company


Most Recent Resources

Advertisement
More Content
  • Voices
  • Photos
  • Podcasts

Mike Reynolds

Reynolds' Rap

Mike Reynolds
December 19, 2009
Perfection Trifecta
The Indianapolis Colts did their part. Now, it’s up to the New Orleans...
More

Todd Spangler

BIT RATE

Todd Spangler
December 19, 2009
Arris Sniffing Around Motorola's Set-Top Unit?
Motorola this week received several bids for its Home & Networks Mobility unit...
More

KEYSTONE HUNT

FREEZE FRAME

Parties, conferences and events for the week of Dec. 14.
HABIT-FORMING

FREEZE FRAME

Conferences, parties and events for the week of Dec. 7.
WOMAN'S WORLD

FREEZE FRAME

Parties, meetings and events for the week of Nov. 30.



Advertisement
About Us   |   Advertising Info   |   Site Map   |   Contact Us   |   Subscription   |   Affiliate Links   |   RSS
© 2011 NewBay Media, LLC. 28 East 28th Street, 12th floor, New York, NY 10016 T (212) 378-0400 F (212) 378-0470
Use of this website is subject to its Terms of Use | Privacy Policy