Uniform Rates For Pole Attachments Would Spur High-Speed
Phoenix Center Thinks Lower Costs Would Lift Broadband Deployment
By Linda Haugsted -- Multichannel News, 12/23/2008 7:52:00 AM
Uniform, lower rates for attaching broadband equipment to utility poles for all telecommunications providers would spur broadband deployment, especially in rural areas, according to a new policy paper by the Phoenix Center for Advanced Legal & Economic Public Policy.
The policy statement from the non-profit think tank concludes that the "current, complicated rate structure" charged by incumbent utilities causes "inefficient investment decisions and generally results in less broadband deployment." A uniform pricing structure would benefit consumers and increase social welfare, the organization opined.
Pole attachment rates paid by, for instance, cable operators who place plant onto telephone poles, are set by the Federal Communications Commission or by state utility commissions. The rates, now averaging in the mid-teens per pole, are set by coming up with the cost of the owning utility for the bare pole and the cost of ongoing maintenance divided among the users of the pole.
But for years, the companies that own the poles have argued that the rates they are paid for using the poles do not reflect modern costs. Also, they argue cable companies that have moved into telecommunications services should pay those higher use rates, not low cable rates, for using the poles.
"The convergence of communications networks has many implications, with one being that the regulated prices for pole attachments should likewise converge," said George Ford, co-author of the study and chief economist at the Phoenix Center. "Having different rates structures for cable and telephone companies might have made sense when congress and the FCC established this system thirty years ago when networks offered very different services. Today, economically efficient pricing implies the pole rate should be common for all broadband providers, and also be much lower than the rates charged today."
-
An alternative solution would be to treat the poles like roads and make the public infrastructure. They could be purchased from the owning companies at a depreciated cost and then all companies using the poles would pay for access. Each provider would still be required to service their own equipment but poles would be replaced by the owning organization.
Otherwise, the only other practical solution would be for each company to install their own poles resulting in three poles at every location currently occupied by a single pole. It is in the best interests of all parties to have a single pole per location and have the rates reasonable enough to encourage sharing.
Aardvark - 12/25/2008 10:45:00 AM EST -
The government should mandate that the cable companies
must buy the network of poles, the installation and
maintenance equipment and hire all the employees
necessary to maintain them then force the cable
companies to provide access at their own cost.
That would spur the electric companies to get into the
business on the backs of the cable companies and we'd
have a new high speed competitor.
Of course when a pole went down we'd be waiting days
for it to be fixed.
Jim D - 12/24/2008 11:03:00 PM EST
VIEW ALL GALLERIES
