Better Business Bureau Refers Comcast 'Fiber-Optic' Claim To FTC
Verizon Had Challenged the Operator's Ad Claim It Provides Services Over A ‘Fiber-Optic Network'
By Todd Spangler -- Multichannel News, 11/4/2009 1:52:33 PM
The National Advertising Division of the Council of Better Business Bureaus has referred Comcast's decision to not participate in the industry group's adjudication process involving the advertising claim that the company provides "fiber-optic network" services to the Federal Trade Commission for further review.
The NAD, acting on a challenge by Verizon Communications, had requested substantiation from Comcast for the advertising claim that it delivers services over a "fiber-optic network."
Verizon contends that Comcast, like virtually all cable companies, uses a hybrid fiber-coax (HFC) network rather than a pure fiber-to-the-home architecture as used by the telco's FiOS. Because Comcast uses coaxial cable to connect to subscribers' homes, the telco argues, Comcast cannot claim to employ a "fiber-optic network."
According to the NAD, Comcast declined to participate citing concerns that Verizon's counsel might have had access to the cable company's "confidential and proprietary information as per a written agreement relating to a multidistrict litigation unrelated to the instant NAD proceeding."
"In this instance, we believe there's a conflict between us and the legal counsel representing Verizon that cannot be resolved, which is why we chose to not participate in the NAD's process," said Comcast senior director of corporate communications Jenni Moyer.
Verizon and its lawyers "disagreed with this characterization," according to the NAD. Neither the NAD nor Comcast identified the litigation referenced.
The NAD's standard procedures dictate that when an advertiser declines to participate in the self-regulatory review the matter is referred to an appropriate governmental agency.
In a statement, Verizon said, "For years Comcast has confused consumers by making false claims that their network is all-fiber-optic like Verizon's. Their refusal to participate in a self-regulatory process is clearly part of their ongoing strategy of delay that allows them to continue making claims that have only one objective -- befuddling consumers. We welcome and eagerly await the FTC's review that we believe will result in Comcast's withdrawal of this false claim."
Verizon has taken issue with cable's use of "fiber optic" marketing claims before. For example, the telco sued Time Warner Cable last year over the MSO's ads claiming it has "been using fiber optics for over a decade," alleging they were intended to mislead customers about the FiOS.
In a statement, NAD said it appreciated "the sincerity and good faith of both parties" but was "disappointed" at Comcast's decision.
In a decision earlier this year regarding Cablevision Systems ads -- also protested by Verizon -- the NAD recommended that Cablevision's "most advanced fiber optic network" claim be discontinued but noted that the cable operator can characterize itself as an "advanced hybrid fiber optic network."
-
verizon will sue someone who farts and doesn't say exactly what kind of fart it was. fiber may be the future but most consumers don't even understand the difference between an optical audio output on their set-top box and a digital coax output... how are to even grasp the network difference between FTTH and a HFC network, they are both fiber, TO A POINT.
this is yet another reason that shows verizon hates competition and thinks they can sue anyone who offers a product that can compete with theirs. maybe comcast shouldn't refer to their system as "fiber-optic" but maybe verizon shouldn't ever refer to themselves as a company who welcomes compeition.
next, are we all going to be sued who have asked "Can you hear me now?" when we think we dropped a cell phone call.
matt - 11/5/2009 8:31:35 PM EST -
Keith is incorrect here. Anything that is past the point of demarcation (the ONT on the side of the FiOS customer's house) is not a part of Verizon's network. It is considered CPE (customer premise equipment).
Verizon's FiOS is a true all-fiber network.
daniel wozniak - 11/5/2009 4:58:11 PM EST -
By Verizon's definition, AT&T and Qwest can't claim to have a fiber-optic network, either.
Moose - 11/4/2009 3:05:47 PM EST -
FioS IS by definition a "hybrid" network - their coax piece is simply a little shorter - at the premise instead of the neighborhood. In fact they often reuse the very same coax within the dwelling that the cable system installed.
When the fiber goes all the way to the TV set or the set-top box then it can truly be called a 100% fiber network.
Keith Hayes - 11/4/2009 2:29:34 PM EST
Verizon Pulls the Fiber Alarm
11/05/2009Coda
11/08/2009D.C. Pols To Light FiOS Sept. 1
08/27/2009Todd Spangler | Multichannel News
11/20/2009
